Bonavita 1900 vs 1901: My Honest Verdict

The Bonavita 1900 vs 1901 debate is simple for most buyers. Both machines make great coffee and use the same SCA-certified brewing system. From my testing, the coffee tastes almost the same, but the Bonavita 1901 is easier to use each day because of its hanging filter basket and updated design. If you want the best mix of brew quality, ease of use, and value, this comparison will help you pick the right model.

Bonavita 1900 Review

I’ve used the Bonavita 1900 for a long time. It is one of the most steady drip coffee makers I have tested. It does not try to do a lot of things. Instead, it focuses on making good coffee every day.

Is Bonavita 1900 good?

Yes, the Bonavita 1900 is a very good coffee maker. I have used many drip brewers over the years. This one still stands out for its brew quality. When I need coffee fast in the morning, I press one button and let it work. In about six minutes, I have a full pot ready to drink.

I have also used it when friends visit. The 8-cup size works well for small groups. The thermal carafe helps keep coffee warm without a hot plate. That means the coffee keeps its taste longer.

One thing I noticed right away was how well it wets the coffee grounds. The large showerhead spreads water across the bed of coffee. The pre-infusion mode helps too. It wets the grounds first, then starts the full brew. This can help bring out more flavor.

The 1500-watt heater is another plus. It keeps the brew water in the ideal range of about 195°F to 205°F. That is one reason why the Bonavita 1900 is SCA certified. I also like how simple it is. There is no screen. There are no complex menus. You just add water, add coffee, and press the button.

What I Like

• Great coffee flavor: In my tests, the Bonavita 1900 made rich and smooth coffee. I got very little bitterness when I used fresh beans and the right grind size.
• Fast brew time: I like that it can brew a full pot in about six minutes. That saves time on busy mornings.
• Simple to use: I press one button and the machine does the rest. The easy design makes daily use stress-free.

What Could Be Better

• No timer: I cannot set it to brew before I wake up. Some users may miss that feature.
• Carafe could pour better: The thermal carafe keeps coffee warm, but the pour can feel a bit slow at times.
• Few extra features: For the price, some coffee makers offer more settings and controls.

Recommendation

Based on my experience, I would recommend the Bonavita 1900 to people who care most about coffee quality. If you buy whole beans, grind fresh coffee, and want a brewer that makes a great cup with little effort, this machine is a strong choice. I think it works very well for many homes in the United States. The fast brew time and thermal carafe fit busy mornings and family use.

Still, if you want a clock, timer, brew strength control, or smart features, you may want to compare a few other models first. For me, the Bonavita 1900 gets the basics right. It heats water to the right temperature. It wets the grounds well. It brews fast. Most of all, it makes coffee that tastes great day after day.

Bonavita 1901 Review

I’ve used the Bonavita 1901 for quite some time. It is a simple coffee maker. Yet it makes very good coffee. If brew quality is your top goal, this machine is easy to like.

Is Bonavita 1901 Good?

Yes. The Bonavita 1901 is a very good coffee maker. I like coffee makers that do the basics well. The Bonavita 1901 does just that. I add water. I add coffee. Then I press one button. On busy work days, I can get a full pot in about six minutes. When family or friends stop by, the 8-cup size gives me enough coffee for all of us.

The coffee tastes rich and clean. I get good flavor from both medium and light roast beans. The wide showerhead helps a lot. It spreads water across the coffee bed in a more even way. The 1500-watt heater is another reason this brewer works so well. It keeps water in the right range for brewing. That helps pull more flavor from the grounds.

I also use the pre-infusion mode at times. It wets the grounds before the main brew starts. When I use fresh beans, I often get a fuller taste and a better smell from the coffee. One change I like over the Bonavita 1900 is the hanging filter basket. It feels easier to use. It also makes cleanup a bit simpler.The best part is that the machine stays simple. There are no screens. There are no hard menus. It is built to make great coffee with little effort.

What I Like

• Great coffee every day: In my use, the Bonavita 1901 makes smooth and rich coffee. The taste stays very close from one brew to the next.
• Better basket design: I like the hanging basket. It is easier to handle than the older design used on the Bonavita 1900.
• Fast and easy brewing: I press one button and let it work. A full carafe is ready in about six minutes.

What Could Be Better

• No timer: I cannot set it to start before I wake up. Some people may want that option.
• Few extra features: There are no brew strength settings or smart controls.
• Best for larger brews: I find that it shines when making several cups. People who brew one small cup at a time may want to look at other options.

Recommendation

I would recommend the Bonavita 1901 to people who care most about coffee taste. If you buy fresh beans and want a brewer that follows good brewing rules, this is a strong choice. I think it fits many U.S. homes well. It brews fast. It is easy to use. The thermal carafe also helps keep coffee hot without a hot plate.

If you want lots of settings, a timer, or smart features, you should compare a few other models first. For me, the Bonavita 1901 gets the key things right. It heats water well. It wets the grounds in an even way. It brews fast. Most of all, it makes a great cup of coffee with very little work.

Bonavita 1900 vs 1901: Detailed Comparison

I have used both the Bonavita 1900 and Bonavita 1901 for a long time. Both make great coffee. The main gap is not the taste. It is the design and day-to-day use.

Brewing Speed: Bonavita 1900 vs 1901

Both coffee makers brew very fast. A full 8-cup pot takes about six minutes on each model. Both use the same 1500-watt heater. I did not see a real speed gap between them.

Quick Comparison

Feature	Bonavita 1900	Bonavita 1901
Brew Time	About 6 minutes	About 6 minutes
Heater	1500W	1500W

My experience: Both were fast. I got my coffee at almost the same time with each brewer.

Rating

• Bonavita 1900: 9.5/10
• Bonavita 1901: 9.5/10

Coffee Temperature: Bonavita 1900 vs 1901

Both brewers hit the right brew range. They keep water between 195°F and 205°F during brewing. This helps make rich and smooth coffee. Both also use a thermal carafe to help keep coffee warm.

Quick Comparison

Feature	Bonavita 1900	Bonavita 1901
Brew Range	195°F–205°F	195°F–205°F
Thermal Carafe	Yes	Yes

My experience: Coffee stayed hot in both carafes. I could not tell much of a gap here.

Rating

• Bonavita 1900: 9.5/10
• Bonavita 1901: 9.5/10

Water Tank Capacity: Bonavita 1900 vs 1901

The two machines have the same size tank. Each brewer can make up to 8 cups. That is about 40 ounces of coffee. This size works well for most homes.

Quick Comparison

Feature	Bonavita 1900	Bonavita 1901
Capacity	8 Cups	8 Cups
Water Volume	40 oz	40 oz

My experience: I never ran out of coffee when making a full batch on either machine.

Rating

• Bonavita 1900: 9/10
• Bonavita 1901: 9/10

Filter Quality: Bonavita 1900 vs 1901

This is the biggest gap between the two. The Bonavita 1900 has a basket that sits on the carafe. The Bonavita 1901 uses a hanging basket that stays on the machine.

The new design is easier to use. It also feels more secure.

Quick Comparison

Feature	Bonavita 1900	Bonavita 1901
Basket Type	On carafe	Hanging basket
Daily Use	Good	Better

My experience: The 1901 felt smoother to use each day. Small things like this matter over time.

Rating

• Bonavita 1900: 8.5/10
• Bonavita 1901: 9.5/10

Brew Quality: Bonavita 1900 vs 1901

Both brewers make excellent coffee. Both are SCA-certified. Both use the same brew system. Both also have a pre-infusion mode to help fresh coffee bloom before brewing.

Quick Comparison

Feature	Bonavita 1900	Bonavita 1901
SCA Certified	Yes	Yes
Pre-Infusion	Yes	Yes
Coffee Taste	Excellent	Excellent

My experience: The coffee tasted almost the same. If I did a blind taste test, I would have a hard time picking a winner.

Rating

• Bonavita 1900: 9.5/10
• Bonavita 1901: 9.5/10

Performance: Bonavita 1900 vs 1901

Both machines perform very well. They brew fast. They heat water well. They make coffee with good flavor and good balance. The 1901 gets a small edge because of its better design.

Quick Comparison

Feature	Bonavita 1900	Bonavita 1901
Brew Quality	Excellent	Excellent
Design	Good	Better

My experience: Both gave me great results. The 1901 just felt a bit more polished.

Rating

• Bonavita 1900: 9/10
• Bonavita 1901: 9.5/10

Ease of Use: Bonavita 1900 vs 1901

Both are easy to use. You press one button and the brew starts. There are no hard menus or extra steps. The hanging basket on the 1901 makes daily use easier.

Quick Comparison

Feature	Bonavita 1900	Bonavita 1901
One-Touch Brew	Yes	Yes
Basket Design	Good	Excellent

My experience: The 1901 saved me a few small steps every day. That made it more pleasant to use.

Rating

• Bonavita 1900: 8.5/10
• Bonavita 1901: 9.5/10

Value for Money: Bonavita 1900 vs 1901

The Bonavita 1900 is often the lower-cost option. The Bonavita 1901 costs a little more. In return, you get a better basket design and a few small updates.

Quick Comparison

Feature	Bonavita 1900	Bonavita 1901
Price	Lower	Slightly Higher
Value	Great	Great

My experience: If the price gap is small, I would pick the 1901. If the 1900 is on sale, it is still a great buy.

Rating

• Bonavita 1900: 9.5/10
• Bonavita 1901: 9.5/10

Overall: Bonavita 1900 vs 1901

The answer is simple. Both machines make great coffee. Both use the same core brew system. Both reach the right brew temperature. Both have pre-infusion mode. The Bonavita 1901 wins because it improves the user experience. The hanging basket is easier to use. The updated design feels more refined.

If the price is close, I would buy the Bonavita 1901. If you find the Bonavita 1900 at a much lower price, it is still one of the best values in drip coffee makers.

Final Ratings

• Bonavita 1900 Overall Rating: 9.1/10
• Bonavita 1901 Overall Rating: 9.4/10

My experience: The coffee in the cup is almost the same. The Bonavita 1901 wins because it fixes small daily issues while keeping the great brew quality that made the Bonavita 1900 so popular.

My Final Thoughts on Bonavita

If you care most about great coffee and simple brewing, Bonavita is a strong choice. If you want timers, touch screens, or lots of brew settings, you may want to look at other brands. From my experience with the Bonavita 1900 vs 1901, both make excellent coffee, but the 1901 feels a bit easier to use each day. Think of it as the same great coffee recipe in a slightly better package. The best pick comes down to whether the updated design is worth the extra cost for you.

FAQs for bonavita 1900 vs 1901

Related Post:

• Ninja CFP201 vs CFP301
• keurig k classic
• keurig k50 review
• Cuisinart SS 15 vs SS 16